Governance

A message from Trust, Member:
I am very proud to have been a part of the Trust’s journey over the years and feel passionately that one of the most important ways for the Trust to thrive is through excellent governance.
The local governing bodies (LABs) set the tone and policies for the school, and ensure the school is going in the right direction. We pride ourselves on recruiting good quality governors who can use their expertise, so we co-opt governors where they have the skills that can add value for the whole school and, in turn, the Trust. I am excited to see where the next few years take us, but we can only fulfil our mission by working together, with the support of our outstanding team of volunteer LAB members, Trustees and Board Members.
Member, Vantage Academy Trust
Expert Governing Team
To ensure strong accountability, effective oversight and excellence across our family of schools, governance at Vantage CE Academies Trust operates through a three-tier structure.
At the highest level, the Members act as the guardians of the Trust’s vision, Christian foundation and charitable purpose. As the Trust’s custodians, they hold the Board of Trustees to account and ensure that the Trust complies with its legal obligations as both a charitable company and an academy trust.
The Board of Trustees provides strategic leadership for the Trust. Trustees are responsible for setting the Trust’s direction, establishing its strategic priorities, monitoring performance, ensuring financial sustainability and holding executive leaders to account for the quality of education and outcomes across all academies.
At school level, Local Advisory Boards (LABs) play a vital role in supporting and challenging school leaders. Drawing on their knowledge of the local community, LAB members provide insight, scrutiny and assurance, helping to hold Principals to account for the educational experience, wellbeing and outcomes of pupils within their academy.
Together, these three layers of governance ensure that Vantage remains true to its Christian ethos and values of aspiration, togetherness and service, while maintaining clear accountability and a relentless focus on enabling every child to flourish.
Members

Trustees

Local Advisory Boards
The main focus of the Local Advisory Boards is to hold individual schools and school leaders to account for school standards, behaviour, quality of teaching and safety of pupils. They set clear expectations, monitor and review progress and achievement for pupils and ensure that school spending represents good value for public money. They monitor and review the quality of teaching and learning, considering feedback from both parents and pupils and ensure that pupils are properly safeguarded. The chairs of all LABs are invited to attend Trustees meetings and present on key local issues, when appropriate.

Chair of Governors

Lev Olexa
Gorton

Robert Scott
Knowsley Lane

Claire Sharpe
SS Simon and Jude

Karina Carter
Flixton Girls

Chris Dugdale
St Paul’s

Jo Hardwidge
St Augustine’s

Ellie Kuitunen
St Barnabas

Sarah Manning
St Hilda’s

Kimberley Ellison
St James

Carolyn Morris
Willow Tree
Key Documents & Statutory Information
Click to view our Articles of Association.
Click to view our Master Funding Agreement & Termination to MFA
Click to view our Scheme of Delegation.
Click to view our Vantage Trust Board Terms of Reference 2026
Click below to view our Committee’s Terms of Reference 2026
Executive Pay & Remuneration and
Click to view our Vantage Code of Conduct.
Click to view our Confirmation of Eligibility.
Click to view our People with Significant Control register.
For more specific information on governance in individual academies, please use the individual school websites links below:
- St Augustine’s
- St Barnabas
- Gorton
- St Hilda’s
- Knowlsey Lace
- St James’
- SS Simon & Jude
- Willow Tree
- Flixton Girls
- St Paul’s
CLICK HERE for our governance portal, The Governor Hub, for those with valid credentials.
Copies of agendas and minutes are available upon request by contacting our Governance Manager:
Rebecca Taylor: Governance@vantageacademies.co.uk
Trustees, Members & Attendance Data 2025-26
| Name | Term of Office | Appointing Body | Meeting Invitations | Meeting Attendance | Apologies | Absent |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Julian Appleyard OBE | 01/11/24 – 31/10/28 | Members | 7 | 4 | 3 | 0 |
| Helena Brothwell | 01/11/24 – 22/09/25 | Members | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Ben Cummins | 01/11/24 – 31/10/28 | Members | 9 | 8 | 1 | 0 |
| Rob Dean | 12/10/21 – 11/10/25 | Members | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Chris Dugdale | 17/12/25 – 16/12/29 | Members | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Lynn Evans | 13/02/25 – 12/02/29 | Members | 7 | 3 | 1 | 3 |
| Natalie Harling | 01/09/26 – 31/08/30 | Members | 7 | 4 | 3 | 0 |
| George Hayes | 25/11/24 – 24/11/28 | Members | 9 | 8 | 1 | 0 |
| Mike Heafield | 13/02/25 – 14/07/26 | Members | 8 | 8 | 0 | 0 |
| Anne-Marie Holmes | 24/07/23 – 08/02/26 | Members | 4 | 3 | 1 | 0 |
| Ross Malkin | 20/09/22 | Foundation/Trust | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Jill Messham | 01/09/23 | CEO | 12 | 12 | 0 | 0 |
| Chris Read | 01/11/24 – 19/07/26 | Members | 9 | 9 | 0 | 0 |
| Deborah Smith | 04/04/23 | Foundation/Trust | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Ned Solanki MBE | 01/11/12 | Original/Signatory/Members | 2 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Nicola Toop | 10/04/25 – 09/04/29 | Members | 9 | 8 | 1 | 0 |
| Sarah Whitty | 05/08/22 – 17/12/25 | Foundation/Trust | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
Current Trustees & Members Register
of Declaration of Interests 2026-27
| Name and appointment | Confirmed | Organisation | Type of interest | Notes | From | To |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name: Julian Appleyard Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 01/11/2024 Term of office end: 31/10/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Pontefract Academies Trust | Other governance role | CEO | 05/03/2018 | |
| Name: Ben Cummins Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 01/11/2024 Term of office end: 31/10/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Equans Services Ltd | Business or finance interests | In my role as a Regional Partnership director I am responsible for the provision of FM services and my company provides services to the education sector. | 01/01/2010 | |
| Name: Chris Dugdale Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 17/12/2025 Term of office end: 16/12/2029 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Hoddlesden St Paul’s CE Primary School | Other governance role | 01/09/2016 | ||
| Name: Chris Dugdale Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 17/12/2025 Term of office end: 16/12/2029 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Meadowhead Junior School | Other governance role | Executive Headteacher | 01/06/2024 | |
| Name: Chris Dugdale Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 17/12/2025 Term of office end: 16/12/2029 | Confirmed 02/09/2026 | St Paul’s, Cross Lane, Salford | Other governance role | Chair of Local Advisory Board | 03/02/2026 | |
| Name: Lynn Evans Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 13/02/2025 Term of office end: 12/02/2029 | Nothing to Declare | |||||
| Name: Natalie Harling Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 01/09/2026 Term of office end: 31/08/2030 | Confirmed 03/09/2026 | Hunter Hall Prep School | Other Governance Role | Chair of Governors | 01/09/2010 | |
| Name: Natalie Harling Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 01/09/2026 Term of office end: 31/08/2030 | Confirmed 03/09/2026 | The Outward Bound Trust | Business or Finance Interest | Director | 01/06/1999 | |
| Name: George Hayes Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 25/11/2024 Term of office end: 24/11/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Cheshire East Borough Council | Local Authority | Elected Member of Cheshire East Borough Council | 01/09/2020 | |
| Name: George Hayes Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 25/11/2024 Term of office end: 24/11/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | The Conservative Party | Member | Member of The Conservative Party | 01/09/2020 | |
| Name: George Hayes Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 25/11/2024 Term of office end: 24/11/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | East Cheshire Chamber of Commerce and Enterprise | Director | Non-remunerated Director of East Cheshire Chamber of Commerce and Enterprise | 01/09/2020 | |
| Name: George Hayes Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 25/11/2024 Term of office end: 24/11/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Buglawton Primary School | Other governance role | Chair of Governors | 01/09/2020 | |
| Name: George Hayes Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 25/11/2024 Term of office end: 24/11/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Talentum Learning Trust | Other governance role | Chair of Members | 01/09/2022 | |
| Name: George Hayes Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 25/11/2024 Term of office end: 24/11/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | H21 Consultancy Ltd | Business or finance interests | Leadership and Governance Consultant | 01/09/2023 | |
| Name: George Hayes Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 25/11/2024 Term of office end: 24/11/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Emmaus Catholic Academy Trust | Business or finance interests | Director of Governance, Risk and Compliance | 01/09/2024 | |
| Name: George Hayes Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 25/11/2024 Term of office end: 24/11/2028 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Greenheart Learning Partnership | Other governance role | Non-Executive Director | 17/09/2025 | |
| Name: Leanne Hornsby Appointment: Trustee (Co-opted) Term of office start: 10/09/2026 Term of office end: 09/09/2030 | Nothing to Declare | |||||
| Name: Rev Ross Malkin Appointment: Member Term of office start: 20/09/2022 Term of office end: | Nothing to Declare | |||||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Diocese of Manchester | Business or finance interests | Hold post of Director of Education | 01/11/2019 | |
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Trinity CofE High School | Member | 01/11/2019 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Cranmer Education Trust | Member | 27/11/2019 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Thrive Church of England Academy Trust | Member | 01/07/2022 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Roch Valley CofE MAT | Member | 15/06/2020 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | The Quill C of E Trust | Member | 31/10/2019 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | The Sycamore CofE Trust | Member | 06/01/2023 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | The Bishop Fraser Trust | Member | 14/12/2023 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Watergrove Trust | Member | 12/12/2025 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Forward as One MAT | Member | 13/12/2022 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Wings CE MAT | Member | 13/05/2024 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Archbishop Temple CE MAT | Member | 05/11/2024 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Leverhulme CE Community MAT | Member | 01/02/2025 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | DBE Services | Director | 31/10/2019 | ||
| Name: Deborah Smith Appointment: Member Term of office start: 04/04/2023 Term of office end: | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Oldham and Henshaw Trust | Director | 05/09/2022 | ||
| Name: Ned Solanki Appointment: Member Term of office start: 01/11/2012 Term of office end: | 01/09/2026 | St Mary’s Hawkshaw | Other Governance Role | Chair of Governors | 01/03/2019 | |
| Name: Nicola Toop Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 10/04/2025 Term of office end: 09/04/2029 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Emmaus Catholic Academy Trust | Business or finance interests | Employed as Chief Finance Officer at Emmaus CAT – a catholic academy trust within the Diocese Of Salford | 15/05/2023 | |
| Name: Nicola Toop Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 10/04/2025 Term of office end: 09/04/2029 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Park Road Primary School | Other governance role | I act as Responsible Officer/ provide Internal Assurance services for Park Road Primary which is single academy trust in Trafford. I do not receive any remuneration for this role but my employer (Emmaus CAT) recharges my time. | 01/09/2019 | |
| Name: Nicola Toop Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 10/04/2025 Term of office end: 09/04/2029 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Knowsley Council | Personal or close family relationship | Sister is School Admissions Team Leader at Knowsley Local Authority and Vantage has schools in Knowsley LA. | 01/09/2000 | |
| Name: Nicola Toop Appointment: Trustee (Member Appointed) Term of office start: 10/04/2025 Term of office end: 09/04/2029 | Confirmed: 02/09/2026 | Cooper Parry | Working relationship | Emmaus CAT also use Cooper Parry auditors. | 10/09/2025 |
Committees
| Business, Audit & Risk | |
|---|---|
| Ben Cummins | Chair |
| George Hayes | |
| Nicola Toop | |
| Lynn Evans |
| Education & Standards | |
|---|---|
| Natalie Harling | |
| Leanne Hornsby | |
| Chris Dugdale | Chair |
| George Hayes |
| Executive Pay & Renumeration | |
|---|---|
| Leanne Hornsby | |
| George Hayes | Chair |
| Nicola Toop |









